Top 7 Natural & Low Tox Eye Creams for Brightening, Depuffing, & Wrinkles

Best Natural & Low Tox Eye Creams for Brightening, Depuffing, & Wrinkles

Looking for a way to keep your eyes looking fresh and bright without all the nasty ingredients? Natural, organic, non-toxic eye creams are here to save the day! Packed with good-for-you ingredients, these creams are gentle on your skin and tough on wrinkles and puffiness. Let’s dive into the best clean eye creams and find out why they are a game-changer for your skincare routine!

This post contains affiliate links.

What’s in this post:

Eye Cream Benefits ✨ (…and do you even NEED one?!)

Before we start, you may be wondering…are eye creams even necessary?! As a skincare junkie, I will still be the first to tell you that, NO, you do not need one in your routine. As long as you’re keeping your eye area hydrated and moisturized (ie. using your facial serums and moisturizers), then you’re still getting some benefits.

However, eye creams are a great way to get additional targeted benefits. The skin around your eyes is particularly delicate and thin and prone to signs of aging, so any extra TLC can go a long way!

(Don’t get me wrong, I do try to embrace my crow’s feet and the aging process. But if I can use something natural to slow the process, then why the heck not!)

Plus, eye creams are typically lighter than products made for your entire face (which can be too heavy for thinner skin). So, if you struggle with milia, for example, using a lightweight cream made especially for the eye area can prevent that!

So, what can eye creams help with? Most fall into these two categories:

  • Brightening and depuffing. Perhaps you have dark circles, swollen eyes, or dullness. Some eye creams help make you look more vibrant, awake, and lifted!
  • Smoothing fine lines and wrinkles. On the other hand, you may struggle with creasing, crow’s feet, wrinkles, loose skin, or dryness. Some eye creams can assist with firming, moisturizing, and plumping.

Some eye creams are formulated to address BOTH!

7 Best Low Tox Eye Cream Brands 👁️

Now, I want to share a couple of awesome eye products made with safe, natural ingredients. I have tried a TON over the years, and these are the best. Depending on what you’re looking for (and all budgets!), there are options that address various concerns.

❌ Icky ingredients you WON’T find in these eye creams:

  • BHT
  • Parabens
  • Paraffin
  • PEGs (polyethylene glycol)
  • Phenoxyethanol
  • Polysorbates
  • Silicones
  • Synthetic fragrances

Index: Ingredients to Avoid (& Printable Pocket Guide)

It’s also important to note that these are not all exclusively “cream” textures—a variety of creams, gel serums, and balms are included. Let’s begin!

100% Pure Coffee Bean Eye Cream (⭐️ Becca’s Top Overall Pick)

$16-29 • Best for brightening • Vegan & Cruelty-Free • Made in USA

100% Pure Coffee Bean Eye Cream

100% Pure is one of my long-time favorites! First of all, it smells like vanilla frosting—yum! It’s a white cream packed with caffeine from green tea and coffee (caffeine has vasoconstrictive properties that help reduce puffiness and dark circles). So it gives you a refreshed, bright-eyed, and bushy-tailed look while nourishing skin!

This cream is also formulated with Vitamin C (brightens skin and pigmentation), Vitamin E (fights free radicals), antioxidants, anti-aging vitamins, and anti-inflammatory goodness.

100% Pure Eye Cream

If I had to choose just ONE, this would be it. It’s a great one that still works well without costing too much money. Additionally, if you’re on a budget, even the smaller tube lasts quite a while!

You can use code ORGANICALLYBECCA for a discount 🏷️

Buy 100% Pure Eye Cream Here

Also available here on Amazon, Love Peace Organic, and The Detox Market.

Agent Nateur Holi(glow) Ageless Eye Serum

$99 • Most deluxe • Versatile for brightening, depuffing, and anti-aging • Cruelty-Free • ECOCERT Organic Certified

Agent Nateur Holi(glow) Ageless Eye Serum

Trust me, I know the price of this Agent Nateur serum is steep. But I’m willing to splurge on a solid eye product that WORKS, especially since I’m in my thirties and trying to be proactive. Not to mention, I only need a tiny pump of serum to cover my entire eye area, and the bottle lasts me well over a year, so yeah, it’s #WorthIt.

I was literally SHOCKED the first time I used this (in a good way!). I have crow’s feet and eye wrinkles when I smile, so I’m always looking for products that blur and ease fine lines around the eye area. This does!!

Agent Nateur Glass Mask and Ageless Eye Serum

The consistency is unique, too! It’s not too oily or heavy, but it has more oomph compared to a water-based serum and leaves my skin nice and moisturized. It even offers a softening, glowy, and luminous effect ✨ (this is due to the pearl powder in the formula, which also means it’s not vegan, FYI)

The serum is ECOCERT organic certified and is loaded with ingredients like hyaluronic acid, caffeine, jojoba, and pitaya. Its delightful smell is due to the first two ingredients: cucumber fruit extract and lavender water! I can definitely tell that it’s quality stuff and makes the delicate skin around my eyes look awake and youthful. (PS, you can use this on your lips too!)

You can use code ORGANICALLYBECCA for a discount on this at Love Peace Organic store 🏷️

Buy Agent Nateur Eye Serum Here

Also available here on Amazon and The Detox Market.

Alpyn Instant Bright Eye Firming Cream

$52 • Best for offsetting dark circles • Vegan & Cruelty-Free • Unscented

Alpyn Instant Bright Eye Firming Cream

Alpyn’s eye cream is GORGEOUS! Both the packaging and the color of the cream. It has a peachy-pink hue but blends in clearly. If you’re not familiar with color theory, peach tones can help offset and correct dark circles and blue/purple tones. Such a smart idea for an eye cream!

Alpyn Instant Bright Eye Cream

It has bakuchiol and reneseed (plant-based retinol alternatives), caffeine, peptides, niacinamide, and chamomile. So it’s meant to firm, tighten, illuminate, and blur lines.

The cream feels hydrating and glides onto skin easily. It also makes a beautiful base for underneath concealer and makeup!

You can use code ORGANICALLYBECCA15 for a discount 🏷️

Buy Alpyn Eye Cream Here

Also available here on Amazon, Sephora, Credo, and The Detox Market.

Related post: “The Top 5 Clean & Natural Concealers (For Dark Circles, Blemishes, and Redness!)

FitGlow Phyto-Retinol Night Eye Balm

$58 • Best for wrinkles and anti-aging • Vegan & Cruelty-Free • Essential Oil-Free

FitGlow Phyto-Retinol Night Eye Balm

FitGlow’s eye balm is wonderful! It’s meant for use at night, but you can totally use it during the day, too. It is a thicker balm-like lotion so it’s the heaviest option in this roundup. But don’t worry; it still absorbs nicely and doesn’t feel too dense.

My favorite part about this balm is that it comes with a dual-sided acupressure tool. One side is flat and should be used to scoop product from the jar and swipe it onto skin, and the other side is a circular metal bulb that you can use to massage the balm in. The wand feels cool and soothing. It is an EXPERIENCE!

FitGlow Phyto-Retinol Night Eye Balm

It’s made with moth bean extract, which is a retinol alternative (derived from a bean, not moths 😆). After consistent use, I really notice an improvement in fine lines!

Lastly, this is made WITHOUT essential oils, but it has a super faint scent naturally from the ingredients.

Buy FitGlow Eye Balm Here

Also available here on Amazon.

Related post: “Your Guide to Clean Retinols & Most Effective Natural Retinol Alternatives

One Love Organics Eyebright Serum

$39 • Most hydrating and lightweight • Vegan & Cruelty-Free • ECOCERT Cosmos Organic • Unscented

One Love Organics Eyebright Serum

What stands out about the One Love Organics serum is the cooling rollerball applicator! I love how fast you can apply this, but it also just has a lovely sensation.

Secondly, it has a viscous gel-serum texture so it’s incredibly hydrating and thin, especially compared to a lotion or balm. It absorbs quickly and won’t leave any residue.

The serum contains eyebright, which I actually didn’t even know was an herb (euphrasia officinalis extract)! Eyebright has traditionally been used in folk medicine, mainly in the treatment of eye disorders. Of course, this serum isn’t used on the eye itself, just the surrounding skin. Eyebright has astringent properties and can be helpful for puffiness and dark circles because it counteracts inflammation. It also has flavonoids, antioxidant-rich astaxanthin, green tea oil, and sea kale!

Buy Eyebright Serum Here

Also available here at Credo and Beauty Heroes.

Three Ships First Light Vitamin C & Caffeine Eye Cream

$32 • Best for depuffing and cooling • Vegan & Cruelty-Free • EWG Verified

Three Ships First Light Vitamin C & Caffeine Eye Cream

Three Ships’ eye cream is special because it has a ceramic tip that cools and glides on smoothly! It’s powered by a plant-based form of Vitamin C from acerola cherries (gentler than synthetic actives) and caffeine from upcycled coffee beans, so you get antioxidant protection, depuffing, and brightening benefits. Plus, it has squalane, which replenishes the skin’s lipid barrier and prevents dryness.

Three Ships First Light Vitamin C & Caffeine Eye Cream

It’s very fast-absorbing and I love that it visibly smooths and tightens skin. I suggest storing this in the fridge so it stays extra cold and refreshing 🧊 (Ohhhh, it feels particularly incredible on those muggy summer mornings or when you wake up with swollen eyes!)

As a coffee lover, I appreciate the subtle coffee smell! (you really have to stick your nose in there to detect it, though)

Buy Three Ships Cream Here

Also available here at Love Peace Organic and The Detox Market.


When using eye cream, use your ring finger to apply and blend! This finger applies less pressure than your pointer finger, so there’s less tugging, and the application is gentler (therefore, fewer lines and wrinkles). And try to do soft taps to apply instead of excess pulling on the skin!

“Better, Not Best” Budget Option: Good Molecules Yerba Mate Wake Up Eye Gel

$6 • Most affordable and accessible • Vegan & Cruelty-Free

Good Molecules Yerba Mate Wake Up Eye Gel

So I recommend the other products in this post first, but if you can’t swing the price on those yet still want something with fewer harmful ingredients, check out this Good Molecules gel! It’s one of the better budget-friendly options out there. Plus, it’s super easy to find in stores like Target and Ulta.

I categorize this as “better, not best” because of one potential ingredient of concern: sodium polyacryloyldimethyl taurate. The rest are fairly clean and safe, though!

It has a gel texture and a lighter, neutral scent. The hero ingredient is sustainably grown yerba mate, which is a rich source of antioxidants and polyphenols that can make skin appear more radiant and energized. It also uses caffeine, hyaluronic acid, and peptides.

Buy Good Molecules Gel Here

Shop the products from this post:

Eye Masks, Gels, & Tools

Bonus! Wanna take your eye care to the next level? Here are some fun tools and masks to add to your self-care ritual.

Eye Masks, Gels, Tools

  • 100% Pure Bright Eyes Masks: Single-use gels made from organic aloe juice and plant cellulose. They contain cucumber and Vitamin C and are highly caffeinated from matcha, green coffee, and yerba mate tea. I always use these before a big event or when traveling on a plane. The most amazing part is that they literally pump hydration into your skin as you wear them (the gels dry out after 20+ minutes) and leave you looking so vibrant.
  • Pacifica Reusable Undereye Masks: Made from high-grade silicone, these can be applied directly to your skin after applying your own eye serum. They have a “vacuum seal” effect and lock in the benefits of your products!
  • Stacked Cryotherapy Ice Roller: Not your average ice roller! It’s smaller and contoured, so you can easily get into those hard-to-reach spots, such as under the eyes and lids! I store mine in the freezer and it helps with inflammation and puffiness.
  • Three Ships Brighter Days Biodegradable Eye Masks: Just wear these for 10 minutes for hydrated, plumped, and softer eyes. When you’re done using them, you can place them in hot water and they will completely dissolve! MAGIC 🪄

Thanks soooooooo much for reading my blog. Are there any products in particular you’re eyeing up? (see what I did there 😉) Let me know if you have any questions in the comments below!

Becca Signature



Top 7 Natural & Low Tox Eye Creams for Brightening, Depuffing, & Wrinkles

Written by: Becca

Becca is a blogger, wife, and dog mom living in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Having seen firsthand the benefits of switching to a natural lifestyle herself, she's passionate about helping women make the switch to clean beauty products, organic skincare, and a holistic way of life (without the stress of being perfect about it!).

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.